Masters of their respective arts

Encounters with two very different geek icons today:

First was the live event with Ray Harryhausen, the master of stop-motion animation, or ‘Dynamation’ as he called it in his heyday. It was pretty much a whistle-stop tour of his life and work, a little over-zealously directed by his biographer(?)/co-author, Tony Dalton.

There were a few nice moments, and of course lots of great clips, if no particularly great revelations. But remarkable to hear that Harryhausen did the bulk of his work alone, given the painstaking, time-consuming nature of stop-frame animation. We’re so used to watching DVD extras full of CG effects animators, each working on tiny aspects of massive effects sequences, that it doesn’t seem possible that one man could produce such an elaborate sequence as the skeleton fight in Jason and the Argonauts:

It might be tempting to say that these old special effects, all Harryhausen’s old ‘creatures’, show their age, or that it’s easy to see the join between live action and miniature animation, but so often with modern CG effects, a similar complaint can be made. What CG very often lacks is the ability to make us overlook the technical shortcomings for the sake of the story, while Harryhausen’s creatures are good little actors (admittedly, they’re often up against very bad actors…) that let you stay involved.

I have to admit I was surprised, when they announced the Festival programme, to find that Harryhausen was still alive - he’s 88 this Saturday. So, good to see the man still going, of no longer working, with a spark in his eye. There were also a few special guests, including one of the skeletons (still posable) from Jason and the Argonauts.

I had to duck out of the final Q&A session to dash over to the Filmhouse for Dreams with Sharp Teeth. Just made it time, and I’m glad I did, because this was probably one of the highlights of the festival so far.

A portrait of the controversial, opinionated SF author Harlan Ellison - a very different presence from the genial Harryhausen. Ellison, who has been writing since the fifties, and baiting controversy for most of the time since, is clearly still very much a firebrand.

But a heartfelt firebrand - Incensed at the idiots he encounters, whether publishers, producers, fanboys, Republicans, fundamentalist or aspiring writers, he’s at least partly frustrated at people’s failure to be as good - as intelligent - as they are capable of.

It’s a highly entertaining film, if always on Ellison’s side, regardless of how explosive he becomes, and it does cover, without sentimentality, some of the childhood trauma that may drive him even now. There are talking heads, ranging from Neil Gaiman to Robin Williams, but Ellison is the true focus throughout. As one of the talking heads (Josh Olsen, sriter of) says: ‘Harlan doesn’t have an off switch; he doesn’t have a censor button. He is simply incapable of sugar-coating it for you.’

The film is interspersed with excerpts from some of his work, of which, I should also probably admit, I have read very little. So, note to self: I must look up some of his work once I’ve escaped Edinburgh (and pay for it - the guy is notoriously litigious).

I Like Bananaz

Bananaz are good.

And very loud, too. Charting 6 years of the progress of Damon Albarn and Jamie Hewlett’s cartoon band Gorillaz, it’s amusing enough, if all rather ‘Britpop is dead. Long live Britpop’. This is a shame in a way, because what I’ve always liked about Gorillaz is that it took Albarn a little apart from that. Here, he comes across as something of a rock’n'roll Jamie Oliver - you get what he’s doing, it tastes good, but you suspect he might get a little slappable after a while.

The film has a similar tone - all lads together - that would be tiresome over a longer period than the film’s 90 minutes.

The music - of course - is the film’s strong suit, and you do get a sense of the sound (as multi-faceted as it is) coming together, particularly in the earlier stages. And the immediacy of recording the music is neatly set off against the slower process of animating the band (and Hewlett’s attendant frustation with the same).

There are lots of nice little moments - Hewlett messing with the American press, Albarn listening to Dennis Hopper record his spoken section for ‘Fire Coming Out of the Monkey’s Head‘, Albarn bluffing madly with an African-American choirmistress over the lyrics her children are singing (from ‘Dirty Harry’: “I need a gun to keep myself from harm” -”No, it’s ‘to keep myself amongst’”)

(I was trying to work out who Jamie Hewlett reminded me of, and it struck me - in the feature film version, he’d be played by Andy Serkis, while Albarn would be played by Jude Law (which doesn’t seem fair, somehow…))

Gorillaz ‘Clint Eastwood’:

International Animation 1

A good selection here (better overall quality than the McLaren selection).

(again, block quotes are from the EIFF website)

Le Grand Content

Clemens Kogler, Karo Szmit / Austria / 2007 / 4 mins

The film demonstrates how systematically disorientation can take place, how logical nonsense can seem.

Powerpoint diagrams of life’s great, and not-so-great, questions. Very funny, the film is inspired by Jessica Hagy’s Indexed cartoons.

The Mouse Trap (Gee-dut)

Woon Han / South Korea / 2007 / 6 mins

A man is like a mousetrap and the city is like a minefield.

Apparently… (looks good, makes no sense)

Bendito Machine

Jossie Malis / Spain / 2006 / 5 mins

A primitive tale about power, corruption, religion and machines… as usual.

Cute little animation, black cut-outs against a bright background (rather like Asian shadow puppets), it’s actually the first in an unfinished series, available online at www.benditomachine.com.

Madame Tutli-Putli

Chris Lavis, Maciek Szczerbowski / Canada / 2007 / 17 mins

Madame Tutli-Putli boards the night train, weighed down with all her earthly possessions and the ghosts of her past.

Creepy, atmospheric stop-motion, let down by a excessively vague ending. The main figure has wonderfully limpid eyes - I could see Audrey Tautou being cast in a live-action version…

Lullaby (Kolibelnaya)

Andrey Zolotukhin / Russian Federation / 2007 / 14 mins

Why did he leave at night? When she was asleep. So not to tear her heart in pieces. So that memories could tear it away.

A disapointment, this one - pretentious and so, so slow…

The Cable Car (Die Seilbahn)

Claudius Gentinetta, Frank Braun / Switzerland / 2008 / 7 mins.

While travelling by cable car to a place somewhere in the mountains, an old man treats himself to some snuff. Et voilĂ ! With every sneeze the cable car cabin is falling more and more apart. The man, however, is far from accepting his fate just like that.

Fairly self-explanatory - funny, but entirely predictable.

The Crumblegiant

John McClosky / United Kingdom, Northern Ireland / 2007 / 5 mins

An old woman remembers a childhood episode and joins this world of memory. Meanwhile the outside world goes on - oblivious.

Very elegant lines, featherweight story.

Wolfie the Pianist

Toshiki Iwahori / Japan / 2007 / 15 mins

Wolfie the Pianist - One day he receives a letter: Dear Wolfie, Please let us hear you play piano. Wolfie begins a journey through deserts carrying his piano with the aim of finding the sender

The director was actually present for this, which is nice. So is the film, which is entirely benign. Lovely textures, as if drawn with pastel on paper.